What the Titanic sub saga and the Greek migrant shipwreck say about our reactions to tragedy
Physics professor explains sub implosion
An investigation is underway to determine why the Titan submersible imploded, killing five people on board, while traveling to the wreckage of the Titanic. Arun Bansil at Northwestern University spoke with LiveNOW from FOX's Josh Breslow to break down how an implosion happens and how it differs from an explosion.
Across the span of nearly a week, the saga of a lost submersible that had gone into the depths of the ocean to see the Titanic wreckage rippled across the national and global conversation — culminating in news that the craft had imploded and its five occupants were dead.
But a far bigger disaster days earlier, the wrecking of a ship off Greece filled with migrants that killed at least 80 people and left a horrifying 500 missing, did not become a moment-by-moment worldwide focus in anywhere near the same way.
One grabbed unrelenting, moment-to-moment attention. One was watched and discussed as another sad, but routine, news story.
READ MORE: Hundreds missing in migrant boat sinking; EU Commissioner says 'worst ever tragedy' in Mediterranean
What makes these two events at sea different in how they were received? Viewed next to each other, what do they say about human reactions to tragic news? And why did the saga of the submersible grab so much attention?
There was an unknown outcome and (we thought) a ticking clock
The Polar Prince, the main support ship for the Titan submersible, arrives at the Port of St. Johns in Newfoundland, Canada, on Saturday June 24, 2023. (Photo by Jordan Pettitt/PA Images via Getty Images)
By the time the world learned about the Greek shipwreck, the event had already taken place and, to some extent, the outcome was already known. All that was left was the aftermath.
Conversely, the Titan (the world thought) was an event in the process of happening — something that unfolded in real time with a deadline attached. As with any narrative, a ticking clock increases tension and attention.
The fact that no one could communicate with the submersible — or learn anything about what the people inside were experiencing — only added to the potential for close attention. And the possibility of a happy ending — at least for a while — also helped sustain attention, said Jennifer Talarico, a psychology professor at Lafayette College in Pennsylvania who studies how people form personal memories of public events.
A well-known historic tragedy was back in the news
The Atlantic Merlin, which was used during the search operation of the Titan submersible, at the Port of St. John's in Newfoundland, Canada. (Photo by Jordan Pettitt/PA Images via Getty Images)
Before anything even went awry, the Titan was already venturing into a realm of existing high interest — the wreck of the Titanic, itself the archetype of modern disasters long before James Cameron's popular 1997 film. So there was an interest already baked in that had nothing to do with the submersible itself.
Cameron's reaction to the Titan disaster only intensified that connection.
READ MORE: Wife of missing sub pilot descended from 2 famous Titanic victims, report says
He told the BBC in an interview broadcast on Friday that he "felt in my bones" that the Titan submersible had been lost soon after he heard it had lost contact with the surface during its descent to the wreckage of the ocean liner at the bottom of the Atlantic Ocean. He said focus in the media over the next few days about the submersible having 96 hours of oxygen supply — and that banging noises had been heard — was a "prolonged and nightmarish charade."
Class and race played a role
Riot police guard the Frontex offices during a demonstration following a deadly migrant shipwreck in Piraeus, Greece on June 18, 2023. (Photo by Dimitris Lampropoulos/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images)
Many reactions and memes this week centered around the notion — fair or not — that one event involved rich people using the ocean as a playground, while the other was a sadly frequent recurrence of misfortune befalling people who lack status, resources or even a voice in the modern marketplace of ideas.
READ MORE: James Cameron says Titanic sub search was a 'nightmarish charade'
Apryl Alexander, a public health professor at University of North Carolina-Charlotte who has studied trauma and survivors, said the migrants on the ship in Greece didn’t seem to engender the same interest from the public as did the wealthy individuals who paid $250,000 apiece to explore the Titanic.
That reminded Alexander of the differences in news coverage of crime in the United States. Crimes get more attention when the victim is white and wealthy compared to a person of color in poverty, Alexander says.
A small group of people had the media's ear
Kathleen Fox and Clifford Harvey from the Transportation Safety Board (TSB) speak to the media at the Port of St. John's in Newfoundland, Canada on Saturday June 24, 2023. (Photo by Jordan Pettitt/PA Images via Getty Images)
Tim Recuber, an assistant professor of sociology at Smith College who studies mass media, digital culture and emotions, says people tend to be drawn to stories that allow them to empathize with the suffering of others — and that it’s easier to empathize when there are smaller numbers of people involved.
READ MORE: Titanic shipwreck: A look at notable people, companies who have made the expedition
"I think some people are calling out this time around the sort of inequalities that are baked into it around class," Recuber said. "We are able to learn who the people on the sub are because of who they are. They’re wealthy and they have access to the press. Divisions of race and national identity matter in terms of who gets empathized with."
The public lives vicariously through others
Individuals who choose their risks have grabbed headlines almost since there have been headlines. So the public was likely enthralled about others cheating death by doing something dangerous, says Daryl Van Tongeren, a psychology professor at Hope College in Michigan who has studied the meaning around big events and their effect on people.
READ MORE: Titanic-bound submersible implosion: Searchers hunt for clues amid complex investigation
In other words, he said, readers and viewers can feel alive by living vicariously through others who are taking risks. "There’s this fascination with people who engage in these high-risk experiences," Van Tongeren said. "Even though we know that death is the only certainty in life, we invest in these activities where we get close to death but overcome it. We want to demonstrate our mastery over death," he said.
Disaster fatigue
A bus transporting survivors of the tragic shipwreck that occurred off the coast of Pylos on June 14th, 2023 and cost the lives of hundreds arrive at Malakasa refugee camp north of Athens on June 16th, 2023. (Photo by Nicolas Koutsokostas/NurPhoto vi
The pandemic. Mass shootings. Economic problems. War. Climate change. It can be hard for another piece of bad news to punch through. "People are starting to tune out," Alexander said.
In the end, she said, she’d like to see the same level of societal interest in human tragedies regardless of race, religion, demographics, or other factors: "For all of us, we hope that if any of our loved ones go missing that the media and the public would pay the same attention to all stories."